<
>

MLB trade deadline 2025: Ranking prospects who changed teams

play
Olney: Eugenio Suárez makes Mariners the best team in AL (1:11)

Buster Olney and Mike Greenberg discuss how the Mariners acquiring Eugenio Suárez elevates their World Series chances. (1:11)

MLB trade season has passed with contenders adding to their rosters for the stretch run ahead and rebuilding teams stockpiling young players with an eye to the future before Thursday's MLB trade deadline struck.

By now, you can probably form your own opinion of the MLB veterans headed to new teams, but it's much more difficult to figure out what to make of the minor leaguers who have moved.

Don't worry, we're here to help. Here's our ranking of every notable prospect (97 of them!) who was dealt during July sorted by tiers using my Future Value grades so you can see where they slot in an MLB top 100 list or your team's farm system ranking.

More: Top 10 prospect rankings for all 30 MLB teams


60 FV tier

1. Leo De Vries, SS, Athletics

Acquired from the San Diego Padres in the Mason Miller deal

Take a moment to consider how rare this sort of deal is. The last prospect of this caliber to be traded was probably Yoan Moncada headlining the trade package for Chris Sale at the 2016 winter meetings. Four years of control after this season of arguably the best reliever in baseball in Mason Miller is quite a prize, but De Vries has star potential, and that's why players like this rarely even get discussed in deals.

De Vries is one of those international signees who had scouts whispering his name as early as age 13 or 14 as the clear best player in his signing class. He signed for a $4.2 million bonus in January 2024. The Padres are aggressive in promoting their top prospects, so De Vries opened his pro career in Low-A as a 17-year-old months after signing his contract, then went to the Arizona Fall League after the 2024 regular season. The switch-hitter has played all of this season in High-A while being the same age as domestic high school seniors.

De Vries has been thrown into the deep end of the pool and has excelled by any measure, with signs that he could grow into stardom. He has present above-average raw power that will grow into 60- or 65-grade raw power along with excellent pull/lift numbers and solid pitch selection that will help him get to all of that power in games, roughly 25-35 homers annually. His bat-to-ball ability plays as roughly average, in part because of the power/pull/lift approach, but the innate ability is above average. Being so young for his level -- the average age at High-A is 22 years old -- obscures his ability a bit, but having tools, performing while switch hitting and playing shortstop at almost four and a half years younger than the average player at your level is something you only see from the best prospects in the sport. None of his offensive splits are worrisome: He performs against velocity, breaking stuff, with two strikes, etc.

Defensively, De Vries has the tools you're looking for -- an easy plus arm, quick and smooth hands -- and some soft skills, like an internal clock and feel for throwing from different platforms. He can get a little lackadaisical at times, but that's somewhat typical for players this talented. De Vries is a fringy runner and his range is below average for a shortstop, so time will tell if he's the kind of defender who can make up for his lackluster range with all of his other abilities, or if he just becomes an above-average defensive third baseman.

You can interpret his talent differently -- he could be a top-five prospect in the game or maybe more in the teens to 20s (I lean the former) -- but he'd be the No. 1 pick in almost any draft.


50 FV tier

2. Eduardo Tait, C, Minnesota Twins

Acquired from the Philadelphia Phillies in the Jhoan Duran deal

Tait is an electrifying prospect with massive raw tools from the enticing demographic of an 18-year-old lefty-hitting catcher. He has some of the biggest raw power in the entire minor leagues, even if you don't adjust for his age. He hit a ball 116.2 mph this season; the average max velo for an 18-year-old minor leaguer is between 103 and 106 mph, depending on how you're qualifying it. And yes, that 116.2 mph rocket was hit 424 feet to the pull side, exiting the entire stadium. Tait has a solid feel for bat-to-ball, but there's a concerning amount of chase, which is in keeping with the power-based, high-effort pull-and-lift approach.

Beyond that, Tait has plus-plus arm strength behind the plate, posting some insane pop times in games but also rushing and losing his mechanics at other times, so his caught-stealing numbers are merely good instead of great. The subtle art of framing is another area where Tait excels -- particularly at the top of the zone -- but his ball blocking and agility suffer as he often can sell out to frame a pitch or set up for a throw to second.

I can see a scenario in which his raw tools carry the profile and he doesn't improve much more, with a career similar to that of Gary Sanchez. Or Tait could really take a step forward and be a future 30- to 40-homer stalwart who also is a solid catcher -- that is to say, a potential star.


3. Khal Stephen, RHP, Cleveland Guardians

Acquired from the Toronto Blue Jays in the Shane Bieber deal

In 2023, Stephen was a mediocre prospect as a starting pitcher at Purdue. He transferred to Mississippi State in 2024 and had a breakout year, improving at almost everything but staying on the board until the 59th pick because he had merely average-or-so raw stuff. Stephen's stock has rocketed up this year not because his stuff got that much better, but because it's now clear he has plus command, which makes his pitches play up a tick or two, akin to George Kirby or the pitcher he was traded for in Bieber.

The velocity, movement and angle of Stephen's fastball make for a fringe-to-average pitch but it plays as at least a 55-grade pitch, while his solid-average slider plays as the same grade. His above-average changeup now plays as at least a 60-grade pitch. It's hard to tell until the upper minors or even majors if Stephen's command is more 55- or 60-grade or maybe even better, but the weak contact allowed this season, largely in A-ball, suggests there's some real magic. His delivery backs up the heat maps and outcomes, and his range of possibilities go from No. 2 to No. 4 starter, likely as soon as next season.


4. Jesus Baez, 3B, St. Louis Cardinals

Acquired from the New York Mets in the Ryan Helsley deal

Baez has a rare combination of plus raw power, plus bat control and the arm strength to stick in the infield. There's still some work to do to reach his upside, though. He is pretty pull-oriented with a flatter swing plane -- so he doesn't always lift the ball as much as he should -- in addition to (understandably) being vulnerable to pitchers with better raw stuff with two strikes. Those are all somewhat expected offensive hurdles with this skill set, but not every prospect can make the adjustments.

Baez splits time between second base, shortstop and third base, but he seems to fit best at third long term. He has an above-average arm that will play anywhere and solid, quick hands. However, he is a below-average runner, so he also has below-average range, which are reasons for his well-below-average defensive metrics. Being an average defensive third baseman isn't a slam dunk, but he can get there with some work. For what it's worth, he looks to me to be a little more comfortable at second base.


5. Mick Abel, RHP, Minnesota Twins

Acquired from the Philadelphia Phillies in the Jhoan Duran deal

Abel was a highly touted draft prospect, going 15th out of an Oregon high school in the 2020 draft, when he was peaking in the upper 90s at 6-foot-5. He only got his walk rate under four per nine innings this season, which is also when he made his big league debut and answered the questions as to whether he could still be a long-term starter.

One big reason for that walk rate improvement is his fastball command, helped by slight delivery/timing adjustments. Abel sits at 94 to 97 mph and hits 99 with a four-seamer that peppers the top of the zone as an above-average pitch, along with a sinker that plays around average. His slider is an above-average pitch that he throws in the strike zone too often to get above-average results. Abel's curveball is a solid average third pitch, and while he doesn't throw it much, his changeup is a solid average pitch when located. With an extra tick of command, he should be a third/fourth starter, and the Twins have a solid track record of teasing that last bit of ability out of talented pitchers -- so it could happen as soon as this season.


45+ FV tier

6. Drew Gilbert, CF, San Francisco Giants

Acquired from New York Mets in Tyler Rogers deal

I was a big fan of the 5-9 Gilbert coming out of Tennessee in the 2022 draft because of his plus speed, plus arm, plus contact rates and average-or-so raw power along with his strong performance in the SEC. He's mostly the same player but has evolved a bit; he'll turn 25 in September and is likely to make his big league debut soon, too. He has lost a tick of speed -- he's now a 55-grade runner who doesn't try to steal many bases -- and is a fringy center fielder who might end up in right field long term, where he'd likely be an above-average defender.

Gilbert's raw power is now a grade better -- also a 55-grade tool -- so you can expect around 20 homers at his peak if his approach holds up. His contact and on-base skills are both similar to what they were in college (plus contact, average chase rate). He can also pull a plus velocity fastball, though keep an eye on his two-strike approach against off-speed stuff from big league arms. That'll be the problem if he sputters a bit when he comes up.


7. James Tibbs, RF, Los Angeles Dodgers

Acquired from Boston Red Sox in Dustin May deal

Tibbs was a first-round pick of the Giants in the 2024 draft but has already been traded twice since then, once in the Rafael Devers trade earlier this season and now again in the May deal. He's a classic right fielder with power-and-patience and 25-homer upside, though he isn't the biggest or most athletic player, so there isn't a ton of margin for error in that projection.


8. Tyler Locklear, 1B, Arizona Diamondbacks

Acquired from Seattle Mariners in Eugenio Suarez deal

Locklear was a college third baseman who moved over to first base full time and has been on a tear this season in Triple-A. He profiles for average contact/on-base ability with above-average power (20-25 homers).


45 FV tier

9. Kohl Drake, LHP, Arizona Diamondbacks

Acquired from Texas Rangers in Merrill Kelly deal

Drake and Kendry Rojas below can be grouped together as they're somewhat similar. Drake is another later-round, small-school find by the Rangers (2022 draft, 11th round from a Tennessee junior college) who has grown into a likely starter with above-average stuff.


10. Kendry Rojas, LHP, Minnesota Twins

Acquired from Toronto Blue Jays in Louis Varland/Ty France deal

As I said in the previous writeup, Drake and Rojas are somewhat similar but here is what sets them apart from each other: Rojas stands 6-2 to Drake's 6-5 but also has above-average stuff and starter command. Rojas is more fluid with a whippier, better arm action, while Drake is bigger and has better feel.


11. Sammy Stafura, SS, Pittsburgh Pirates

Acquired from Cincinnati Reds in Ke'Bryan Hayes deal

Stafura was the No. 43 pick in 2023 and signed for an overslot $2.5 million out of New York high school. The scouting report now is still pretty similar to what it was then: he's a plus athlete with easy plus speed who has a shot to stick at shortstop and above-average power potential but might be a 40-grade hitter (.230 average or so), which could undermine the profile. He has the tools to stick at shortstop and makes the plays, but he can be upright and stiff at times.

He has solid pitch recognition, bat speed and ball flight, which are the basic components to success as a hitter in the big leagues. That said, Stafura's timing against mid-90s or better velocity and steep bat path (i.e., geared for fly balls) will cause many more whiffs at higher levels against better pitching, so adjustments will be necessary.


12. Roc Riggio, 2B, Colorado Rockies

Acquired from New York Yankees in Jake Bird deal

Riggio has improved his defense and contact ability since college (he was a fourth-round pick out of Oklahoma State in 2023), but still has the power-and-patience that he's been showing scouts for years.


40+ FV tier

13. Hunter Feduccia, C, Tampa Bay Rays

Acquired from Los Angeles Dodgers in Zack Littell deal

14. Rafael Flores, C, Pittsburgh Pirates

Acquired from New York Yankees in David Bednar deal

I'll lump these two together since they're both older-for-the-level catchers in the upper minors leaving contending teams that didn't have a spot for them. Feduccia has better on-base skills and overall defensive ability, while Flores has more power and is a better framer. Both should get a look in the big leagues late this year or early next year.


15. Brandyn Garcia, LHP, Arizona Diamondbacks

Acquired from Seattle Mariners in Josh Naylor deal

A 2023 11th-rounder out of Texas A&M, Garcia was a sleeper in the Seattle system who broke through as a starter in 2024. This season, he was moved into a full-time relief role, leading to his big league debut earlier this month.

He has an upper-body-reliant delivery with very short extension and a near-sidearm slot that nonetheless creates a lot of velocity, with his fastball peaking at 100.4 mph this season and living at 95-98 mph with his plus sinker. He also mixes in an 88-90 mph cutter and 84-86 mph sweeper that are both plus pitches. Garcia's fastball command improving and the cutter continuing to be a useful weapon against righties are keys to him becoming a late-inning reliever.


16. Jadher Areinamo, SS, Tampa Bay Rays

Acquired from Milwaukee Brewers in Danny Jansen deal

Areinamo is listed at 5-8, is a below-average runner and has below-average range that will keep him from being a long-term everyday shortstop; he's already splitting time between shortstop and second/third base in High-A this year. Those facts limit his upside a bit, though he has an average arm and can catch the ball when he gets to it. The sales pitch is that he's growing into fringe-to-average power with a sometimes wild swing but manages to also post plus contact rates. The offensive hesitation is that Areinamo, as his swing suggests, can get a little wild chasing pitches out of the zone, even if his standout bat control bails him out of some bad swing decisions. With some progress on his chase rate, Areinamo could move from a projected platoon guy to a lower-end starter at second base.


17. Blaze Jordan, 3B, St. Louis Cardinals

Acquired from Boston Red Sox in Steven Matz trade

Jordan has been famous since his underclassman years in high school, when he was one of the early developers in his class. He has improved defensively at third but still plays some first base. At the plate, he has plus bat-to-ball and power potential but still chases out of the zone too much and doesn't lift the ball as much as he should.


18. Blade Tidwell, RHP, San Francisco Giants

Acquired from New York Mets in Tyler Rogers deal

Tidwell is a good athlete with a fine delivery who is a classic control-over-command pitcher -- meaning he can throw any of his pitches over the plate, but has trouble hitting specific spots regularly. Despite his raw stuff being above average, and him already starting big league games, many evaluators worry he's more of a multi-inning reliever than a true starter.

His four-seam fastball plays down a tick or two from its plus velocity due to the locations and plane/shape. He seems like a better fit to rely more on his sinker as his primary fastball given his steep angle into the strike zone tied to his higher arm slot. His slider is roughly average but he throws it in the strike zone way too much, so it's getting hammered, while his sweeper is above average by movement but he locates it well and it's performing above average, too He doesn't use his changeup much and it's around average.

Tidwell is on the back-end starter/middle reliever (who is also a spot starter) spectrum and it may take until this time next year to have a better idea of what he'll be.


19. Boston Bateman, LHP, Baltimore Orioles

Acquired from San Diego Padres in Ramon Laureano/Ryan O'Hearn deal

Bateman is a 6-8 lefty who was a second-round pick from a SoCal high school in last year's draft. He has solid-average stuff headlined by his slider, along with some feel, projecting as a backend starter.


20. Jesus Rodriguez, C, San Francisco Giants

Acquired from New York Yankees in Camilo Doval deal

Rodriguez has above-average framing ability and arm strength behind the plate along with above-average bat-to-ball ability and some patience, but probably not enough power to profile as an every-day catcher


21. Cobb Hightower, SS, Baltimore Orioles

Acquired from San Diego Padres in Ramon Laureano/Ryan O'Hearn deal

Hightower was a surprising third-round pick from a North Carolina high school last year who was raw but also old for his high school class. The tools are real -- plus speed, a shot to stick at short, on-base skills and double-digit homer upside -- but his polish still needs to come.


22. Adam Serwinowski, LHP, Los Angeles Dodgers

Acquired from Cincinnati Reds in Zack Littell deal

Serwinowski is a lanky, 6-5 lefty with two above-average pitches in his fastball and slider, though his third pitch and command still need to come a bit. He'd fit well in relief if they don't.


40 FV Tier

23. Christian Franklin, CF, WSH (from CHC - Michael Soroka)
24. Jorge Quintana, SS, SD (from MIL - Nestor Cortes)
25. Griffin Herring, LHP, COL (from NYY - Ryan McMahon)
26. Edgleen Perez, C, PIT (from NYY - David Bednar)
27. Zack Ehrhard, RF, LAD (from BOS - Dustin May)
28. Juan Burgos, RHP, ARI (from SEA - Eugenio Suarez)
29. Mitch Bratt, LHP, ARI (from TEX - Merrill Kelly)
30. Wellington Aracena, RHP, BAL (from NYM - Gregory Soto)
31. Enrique Jimenez, C, MIN (from DET - Chris Paddack)
32. Ashton Izzi, RHP, ARI (from SEA - Josh Naylor)
33. Braden Nett, RHP, ATH (from SD - Mason Miller)
34. David Hagaman, RHP, ARI (from TEX - Merrill Kelly)
35. Everson Pereira, CF, TBI (from NYY - Jose Caballero)
36. Callan Moss, 1B, PIT (from KC - Bailey Falter)
37. Juaron Watts-Brown, RHP, BAL (from TOR - Seranthony Dominguez)
38. Nate Dohm, RHP, STL (from NYM - Ryan Helsley)
39. Tyson Neighbors, RHP, BAL (from SD - Laureano/O'Hearn)
40. Jeter Martinez, RHP, PIT (from SEA - Caleb Ferguson)
41. Ryan Bergert, RHP, KC (from SD - Freddy Fermin)
42. Chase Jaworsky, SS, MIA (from HOU - Jesus Sanchez)
43. Henry Baez, RHP, ATH (from SD - Mason Miller)
44. Anthony Nunez, RHP, BAL (from NYM - Cedric Mullins)
45. Hendry Mendez, LF, MIN (from PHI - Harrison Bader)
46. Raimon Gomez, RHP, BAL (from NYM - Cedric Mullins)
47. Andrew Hoffman, RHP, ARI (from KC - Randal Grichuk)
48. Sean Paul Linan, RHP, WSH (from LAD - Alex Call)
49. Trystan Vrieling, RHP, SF (from NYY - Camilo Doval)


35+ FV Tier

50. Brandon Lockridge, CF, MIL (from SD - Nestor Cortes)
51. Esmil Valencia, CF, MIA (from HOU - Jesus Sanchez)
52. Ronny Cruz, SS, WSH (from CHC - Michael Soroka)
53. Ben Shields, LHP, COL (from NYY - Jake Bird)
54. Skylar Hales, RHP, STL (from TEX - Phil Maton)
55. Hunter Cranton, RHP, ARI (from SEA - Eugenio Suarez)
56. Yunior Marte, RHP, SF (from KC - Mike Yastrzemski)
57. Clayton Beeter, RHP, WSH (from NYY - Amed Rosario)
58. Brian Sanchez, CF, PIT (from NYY - David Bednar)
59. Wilfri De La Cruz, SS, BAL (from CHC - Andrew Kittredge)
60. Ryan Gallagher, RHP, MIN (from CHC - Willi Castro)
61. Josh Randall, RHP, WSH (from DET - Kyle Finnegan)
62. Eduarniel Nunez, RHP, ATH (from SD - Mason Miller)
63. Jake Eder, LHP, WSH (from LAA - Chafin/Garcia)
64. Paul Gervase, RHP, LAD (from TBR - Zack Littell)
65. Gage Ziehl, RHP, CHW (from NYY - Austin Slater)
66. Matthew Etzel, LF, MIA (from TBR - Nick Fortes)
67. Browm Martinez, CF, WSH (from NYY - Amed Rosario)
68. Josueth Quinonez, CF, DET (from PHI - Matt Manning)
69. Brandon Valenzuela, C, TOR (from SD - Will Wagner)
70. Eriq Swan, RHP, WSH (from LAD - Alex Call)
71. Mason Molina, LHP, STL (from TEX - Phil Maton)
72. Brian Van Belle, RHP, TBR (from CIN - Zack Littell)
73. Garrett Horn, LHP, MIN (from TEX - Danny Coulombe)
74. Josh Grosz, RHP, COL (from NYY - Ryan McMahon)
75. Ben Peoples, RHP, CHW (from TBR - Adrian Houser)
76. Sam Brown, 1B, WSH (from LAA - Chafin/Garcia)
77. Parks Harber, 3B, SF (from NYY - Camilo Doval)
78. Evan Sisk, LHP, PIT (from KC - Bailey Falter)
79. Brandon Butterworth, 2B, BAL (from SD - Laureano/O'Hearn)
80. Ivan Brethowr, RF, PIT (from CHC - Taylor Rogers)
81. Frank Elisalt, RHP, STL (from NYM - Ryan Helsley)
82. Micah Ashman, LHP, BAL (from DET - Charlie Morton)
83. Cameron Foster, RHP, BAL (from NYM - Gregory Soto)
84. Chandler Marsh, RHP, BAL (from NYM - Cedric Mullins)
85. R.J. Sales, RHP, WSH (from DET - Kyle Finnegan)
86. Twine Palmer, RHP, BAL (from HOU - Ramon Urias)
87. Kenya Huggins, RHP, ATH (from CIN - Miguel Andujar)
88. Carlos De La Rosa, LHP, SF (from NYY - Camilo Doval)


35 FV tier

89. Wilberson De Pena, LF, LAA (from NYY - Oswald Peraza)
90. Duncan Davitt, RHP, CHW (from TBR - Adrian Houser)
91. Victor Figueroa, 1B, BAL (from SD - Laureano/O'Hearn)
92. Geremy Villoria, RHP, MIN (from PHI - Harrison Bader)
93. Tanner Smith, RHP, BAL (from SD - Laureano/O'Hearn)
94. Sam Armstrong, RHP, MIN (from CHC - Willi Castro)
95. Austin Smith, RHP, COL (from ATL - Tyler Kinley)
96. Jim Jarvis, SS, ATL (from DET - Rafael Montero)
97. Matt Mikulski, LHP, MIN (from HOU - Carlos Correa)